Don’t let them fool you, these Witts, with their Colgate smiles and constant giggles and impossibly amiable personalities.

Then again, how could you not be fooled?

Was that McKenna in the Oakleys or Madison? Wasn’t McKenna on the right? Or did they switch?

Hold on…it was Madison with the 4-centimeter tear in her ab…right? Or was that the other one, the one who looks just like her, down to the cascade of blonde hair and almond-shaped eyes and what they call “twig-noodle” frames?

Kerri Walsh couldn’t figure it out when she played the Madison and McKenna Witt in 2016. Neither could their high school teachers on the one occasion they swapped places in math and Spanish, though so overwhelming was their guilt and nerves that they never did it again.

“I was so nervous,” McKenna Witt, now McKenna Thibodeau, said.

Yes, the Witt sisters are technically no longer. McKenna is now a Thibodeau, and Madison, recently engaged, will soon become a Willis.

The Thibodeau-Willis sisters don’t exactly have the same ring as the Witt Sisters. No matter. They still have the same identical looks, despite an NVL official once attempting to change exactly that, marking Madison with a No. 1.

Or hold on. Was that McKenna?

Read the rest of the story and listen in at!

If you like us, let us know and subscribe give a review on iTunes!

Follow us on Podbean to catch up with all episodes!

If you’re digging what we’re wearing, go ahead and give our sponsors some love at Plastic Clothing!

If you’re looking for some new board shorts or bikinis, check out Rox and their 80 PERCENT OFF SALE!

Popular on SANDCAST:
SANDCAST 20: Brotherly love with Maddison McKibbin
SANDCAST 17: Is p1440 the next big thing in beach volleyball?
SANDCAST 13: Sara Hughes embraces new responsibility: Role model
SANDCAST 12: Talking’ sh** with Trevor Crabb
SANDCAST No. 9: Chase Frishman and the AVP’s next wave of talent
SANDCAST 8: Phil Dalhausser has another mountain to climb
SANDCAST 6: A glimpse into greatness with April Ross, Part 2
SANDCAST 5: A glimpse into greatness with April Ross, Part 1
SANDCAST 3: It’s finally (finally) video game season for Kelly Claes
SANDCAST 1: The new Tri Bourne: Buddha Tri Bourne

Recover the right way with Firefly: Accelerated Athletic Recovery


This podcast would not be possible without our generous sponsors from Marriott Vacation Club Rentals, which offer the best vacation accommodations in the world’s best vacation destinations. Wherever you travel… Florida to Hawaii, Europe to California, choose to rest in our luxurious guest rooms, suites or villas for your next getaway. Villas offer all of the comforts of home including a full kitchen, living and dining area and separate bedrooms. Stay with the Marriott name you know and trust.   
Book Big Spaces in Great Places today. Visit

Choose the ball the pros use. Choose Wilson. 

Wilson Volleyball