KAUAI, Hawaii – In the wake of Wednesday’s mailbag, in which I discussed, amongst many topics of the beach volleyball universe, my overall distaste for the current Olympic format, a listener asked me to “tell us more about what you hate about the Olympic format. I’m all for double-elim, but what about the format do you dislike?”

That’s a fair question.

First, an explainer of the current format.

The Olympics operate in a 24-team round-robin format featuring six pools of four teams. Every team plays against one another in pool, with the top three breaking into the playoff rounds.

Here’s what I dislike about it: The lack of incentives.

There is minimal reward for winning, and minimal consequences for losing. Case in point: Cuba’s Jorge Alayo and Noslen Diaz finished pool in the Paris Olympic Games 3-0 and were one of the most exciting teams in the field. Sweden’s David Ahman and Jonatan Hellvig were a shell of themselves, going 1-2. Yet they began in the same round as Cuba, even playing Alayo and Diaz in the first round. Sweden won that match, and every other match, finishing with a gold medal draped around their necks.

The women’s side featured something similar: USA Volleyball’s Kristen Nuss and Taryn Brasher went 3-0, while Canada’s Melissa Humana-Paredes and Brandie Wilkerson went 1-2. They, too, met in the round of 16, a match won by Canada, who then finished the tournament with silver medals draped around their necks. This in spite of three total losses in the tournament.

Both Cuba and Nuss and Brasher were rewarded minimally for winning, and Sweden and Canada suffered virtually zero consequences for losing.

That would be the central gripe of the format.

How I’d fix the Olympic format

So: What’s the fix?

The easiest solution, to me, would be to expand the field to 32, while increasing the country quota to three teams per country as opposed to the current two. Run a double-elimination tournament from there, as they did in 1996 in Atlanta.

But if I had to work within the confines of a 24-team field, as will be the case in Los Angeles in 2028, I actually wouldn’t run a double-elim. Why?

Because in a 24-team double-elimination, you’d have eight teams begin with a bye. This is all well and good: Those top eight teams deserve a reward for entering the Olympics as one of the top eight teams throughout a long and grueling Olympic quad.

The problem rests in the bottom 16 teams, who would play one another in the first round. The winners of that first round would play one of the eight teams receiving a bye. But if you win your first, and lose your second, you’d drop into the same round as the teams who didn’t win at all.

You’d receive no reward for winning that first match.

I don’t find that to be justifiable.

Modified pool, too, has its faults.

In a modified pool play format, the teams seeded one and four would play each other, and teams seeded two and three would play one another. The winners of each matchup then meet, as do the losers.

Sounds nice, and in a 32-team format, it’s excellent. But here’s the issue in a 24-team field: The teams who won have zero reward or consequence in their next match. Regardless of the result of that match, they would begin playoffs in the exact same round.

No reward for winning, no consequence for losing.

This is why we witnessed the rash of forfeits when the Beach Pro Tour ran a 24-team modified pool system in the Challenge events: A complete and total lack of incentive.

How I’d run a 24-team tournament — and 24 is the most brutal number there is — would be to split into eight pools of three in a round-robin style tournament.

A sweep win would be worth three points. A three-set win would be worth two. A three-set loss would be worth one. A sweep loss would be zero.

Tiebreaks would be decided on point differential throughout pool play.

The top two from each pool break into a 16-team, single-elimination bracket.

It’s messy, yes, and I loathe tournaments that require calculators, but it’s a format that has rewards and consequences not only for every match, but every set. And at the end of the day, that, above all else, is my operating principle: Rewards for winning, consequences for losing.

Anyway, it’s a good question, and I thought I’d answer it, and hope someone in a meaningful position will hear this or watch this or read this and expand the field to 32 teams.